First Choice Car Care

463670 State Road 200 Yulee, FL 32097

Hours today:  7:00 AM - 6:00 PM CLOSED

Hours & Details

  • Monday
  • Tuesday
  • Wednesday
  • Thursday
  • Friday
  • Saturday
  • Sunday CLOSED
Credit cards accepted:
Goodyear Credit Card Visa MasterCard American Express Discover

Ratings & Reviews

3.3 out of 5

(7 reviews)
5 stars
(4)
4 stars
(0)
3 stars
(0)
2 stars
(0)
1 stars
(3)

Made an online order and scheduled the appointment. The service manager John called me a day later to confirm the appointment and purchase. Very nice guy. My appointment was Friday morning. I dropped off my trailer tires on Thursday evening around 415pm and met John and told him I knew my appointment was tomorrow morning, but wanted to make sure I could pick the tires up by lunch time on Friday. He said no worries and I went home. Got a call at 530pm on Thursday that said my tires were done and ready for pickup. Excellent service!!

I bought a set of tires at First Choice Goodyear, Yulee, FL recently, paying about $1,000 for the tires and other work done. The next day, one of the new tires deflated. We brought the car in to have it repaired, and when it was returned, that tire was making loud clunking noises. I brought it back again, and they told me the struts are not working properly and it would cost $900 to fix it. I'm extremely dissatisfied and not inclined to shop at this store any longer. I've done quite a bit of business over the years at this store, but not taking responsibility for this is inexcusable.

I have been using this mechanic for years across many different vehicles, for many different services. They are honest and direct to the point of what is needed, what can wait and what isn't needed. Whenever there have been ANY issues, Mike made sure they were corrected quickly. On a couple occasions, he took me out to the bay that my vehicle was in to give a visual of potential concerns and why. Personally, I trust their service and they have gone above and beyond every time I have used them.

Store Offerings

This store is an independently owned and operated location.

  • Wi-Fi in Waiting Room
  • Offers Shuttle Or Vehicle Pickup
  • 6 Months No Interest
  • 12 Months No Interest
  • 60-Minute Installation Guaranteed (on most vehicles)
  • Check and fill tire air pressure with any service
  • Check and top-off fluids with any service
  • Courtesy Shuttle Service
  • Free Air
  • Free Mounting/Free Rotation Every 6,000 miles with tire purchase
  • Largest selection of Goodyear products
  • Quality parts and service backed by a nationwide limited warranty
  • Work done right by expert ASE-certified technicians
  • Member of the Motorist Assurance Program (MAP)
  • Provide manufacturer's recommended maintenance schedule

Specialists on Staff:

  • Performance Tire Specialist
  • Winter Tire Specialists


The content and images on this page related to an Independent Goodyear Dealer are provided and owned by that Independent Goodyear Dealer. Goodyear disclaims all responsibility and liability for any content or images provided by the Independent Dealer. Goodyear has not independently verified the accuracy of the information provided by the Independent Dealer, and the descriptions and images may not be accurate.

Services Offered

  • Air Conditioning
  • Batteries
  • Belts & Hoses
  • Brake Systems Repair
  • Drivelines
  • Electrical Systems
  • Engine Diagnostics
  • Fluid Exchange Services
  • Headlamps & Bulbs
  • Heating & Coolant Systems
  • Mufflers & Exhaust
  • Oil, Lube & Filter Services
  • Preventative Maintenance Packages
  • Shocks & Struts
  • Starting & Charging Systems
  • State Inspection
  • Steering & Suspension Systems
  • Timing Belts
  • Tire Installation
  • Tire Pressure Monitoring Systems
  • Tire Repair
  • Tire Rotation
  • Tune-Ups
  • Wheel Alignment
  • Wheel and Tire Balancing
  • Wiper Blades

Learn More About Services


The content and images on this page related to an Independent Goodyear Dealer are provided and owned by that Independent Goodyear Dealer. Goodyear disclaims all responsibility and liability for any content or images provided by the Independent Dealer. Goodyear has not independently verified the accuracy of the information provided by the Independent Dealer, and the descriptions and images may not be accurate.

About This Store

Our mission statement is simple. We strive to offer top-notch mechanical and preventive maintenance services and aggressively priced multi-brands of discount tires backed by unparalleled customer service. First Choice Car Care (Goodyear) was built on a foundation of going above and beyond for our clients. It starts with Mike and Laura and extends to every employee under our roof.


The content and images on this page related to an Independent Goodyear Dealer are provided and owned by that Independent Goodyear Dealer. Goodyear disclaims all responsibility and liability for any content or images provided by the Independent Dealer. Goodyear has not independently verified the accuracy of the information provided by the Independent Dealer, and the descriptions and images may not be accurate.

If you have a complaint about copyright infringement, please click here.